bonus

Talent Trade Tidbit - Interviewing As An Internal Candidate

Published on: 25th June, 2026

While you might think you've got a better position at your existing company all locked up, that doesn't mean you can coast through the interview. ThinkingAhead’s Jonathan McIntosh explains how to help those familiar colleagues see you in a different light...

Discover what sets ThinkingAhead apart, hear stories from recruiters, and browse opportunities by clicking here.

Transcript
Speaker:

Almost every role we recruit for these days, there's an internal candidate who's already been in the organization that's applying for this larger role.

Speaker:

Despite what a lot of people may think, the internal candidate is rarely a shoo-in for the job.

Speaker:

What it comes down to is that board members and leaders who've seen you in one capacity have a hard time imagining you in that expanded capacity.

Speaker:

Even Jesus said, "A prophet has no honor in his own hometown." They've only seen you do this one thing.

Speaker:

Certainly, you're larger than what you've done for that one organization, and they may not even know all the complexities and successes of your job.

Speaker:

So it's up to you to help them see you in that expanded light.

Speaker:

That often comes down to two words.

Speaker:

One is executive presence.

Speaker:

Now, a lot of that's about optics, but it's also about confidence.

Speaker:

Do we have the confidence in their ability to lead at this level?

Speaker:

I'm not encouraging you to lose your sense of humor or whimsy or what makes you special, but you do have to walk into those interview rooms with a sense of authority and command and projecting the confidence that you are ready to lead at this level.

Speaker:

And the second thing that they're looking for is strategic thinking.

Speaker:

You have been in the department.

Speaker:

Are you now ready to lead the department?

Speaker:

You've been in the trenches day to day doing the operations of the organization, but can you pull yourself out of the day to day and think about the picture as a whole?

Speaker:

And you've got to demonstrate that you're ready and that you see all of the different facets, that you see all of the different pixels in the picture, and you're ready to handle this larger scope.

Speaker:

And so you want to, in the interview process, give them a sense of your larger, more strategic thinking, not just your day-to-day tactical

Speaker:

operations.

All Episodes Previous Episode

Support The Talent Trade

A huge thank you to our supporters, it means a lot that you support our podcast.

If you like the podcast and want to support it, too, you can leave us a tip using the button below. We really appreciate it and it only takes a moment!
Support The Talent Trade
A
We haven’t had any Tips yet :( Maybe you could be the first!
Show artwork for The Talent Trade

About the Podcast

The Talent Trade
Presented by ThinkingAhead Executive Search
The Talent Trade is all about finding the right person, for the right opportunity, at the right time. But how exactly do you do that the "right" way? Executive Search Partner and Top Biller Stephanie Maas shares more than 25 years of experience about what it takes to be a top recruiter in today's "talent trade" market, using ThinkingAhead’s four-prong system focused on recruiting, business development, planning, and managing your mindset. It’s real, honest information about how to build your desk, perfect your niche, and stand out among the crowd in your search career.



Southwestern/Great American, Inc., dba Southwestern Family of Companies, for itself and its related entities and their assigns, reserves and retains all rights to their copyrighted materials and trademarks contained in this podcast.
Support This Show